Comparative and Noncomparative Advertising

Topics: Advertising, Effect size, Brand Pages: 60 (12182 words) Published: November 19, 2010
Dhruv Grewal, Sukumar Kavanoor, Edward F. Fern, Carolyn Costley, & James Barnes

Comparative Versus Noncomparative Advertising: A Meta-Analysis Previous research and reviews on comparative advertising report mixed results. The authors report the results from a meta-analysis that examines the efficacy of comparative advertising. The analysis shows that comparative ads are more effective than noncomparative ads in generating attention, message and brand awareness, levels of message processing, favorable sponsored brand attitudes, and increased purchase intentions and purchase behaviors. However, comparative ads evoke lower source believability and a less favorable attitude toward the ad. Additional analyses of moderator variables find that market position (sponsor, comparison, and relative), enhanced credibility, message content, and type of dependent measure (relative versus nonrelative) affect some of the relationships between advertising format and cognition, brand attitudes, and purchase intentions. New brands comparing themselves to established brands appear to benefit most from comparative advertising.


omparative advertising has become increasingly prevalent in the United States media. Some examples of the many advertising campaigns using comparative advertising include MCI comparing its long-distance call prices and service to AT&T; VISA comparing the number of merchants accepting its credit card to American Express; Burger King comparing its cooking method to McDonald's; and various beverage producers challenging competitors in taste tests. Recent estimates indicate that comparative advertising formats account for one-third of all advertisements (Neiman 1987; Stewart and Furse 1986) and close to 80% of all television commercials (Pechmann and Stewart 1990b). Comparative advertising's increased popularity may be partly due to the Federal Trade Commission's informal encouragement of explicit comparisons (Tannenbaum 1974; Wilkie and Farris 1975), as well as to advertisers' beliefs in its effectiveness. The FTC rationalized that explicit comparative advertisements deliver infonnation previously unavailable to consumers (Wilkie and Farris 1975). The FTC's implicit encouragement of brand comparisons, along with relaxed restrictions and competitor and media concerns (Tannenbaum 1974), sparked the research interest of academicians and practitioners alike. The effectiveness of comparative advertising, according to the large body of extant empirical research, is equivocal. Some investigators conclude that comparative advertising Dhruv Grewal is Associate Professor of Marketing, University of Miami. Sukumar Kavanoor is a marketing consuitant, The Janus Group. Edward Fern Is Associate Professor of Marketing, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University. Carolyn Costley Is a lecturer. University of Waikato. James Barnes is Professor of Marketing, University of Mississippi. This article has benefited from the comments and suggestions of Connie Pechmann, Paul Miniard, Diana Grewal, and the four anonymous JM reviewers. The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support from a University of Miami Summer Research Grant.

provides advantages that are not associated with noncomparative advertising (e.g., Droge and Darmon 1987; Miniard et al. 1993; Pechmann and Ratneshwar 1991; Pechmann and Stewart 1990a; Rose et al. 1993). Others report that comparative advertising produces undesirable outcomes (e.g.. Belch 1981; Golden 1979; Goodwin and Etgar 1980; Levine 1976; Swinyard 1981). These conflicting opinions do not seem to deter major consumer goods and service corporations from using comparative advertising in their promotional mix. The prevalence of comparative ads in the face of the conflicting empirical evidence about their effectiveness suggests that this topic should be important to researchers and practitioners. There have been several attempts to consolidate research findings in this area (e.g., Barry 1993;...

References: to Competitors in Comparative Advertising," Journal of Advertising, 15 (March), 10-23. Hill, R. (1989), "An Exploration of Voter Responses to Political Advertisements," Journal of Advertising, 18 (December), 14-22. Hunter, John E. and Frank L. Schmidt (1990), Methods of MetaAnalysis. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications. Iyer, Easwar S. (1988), "The Influence of Verbal Content and Relative Newness on the Effectiveness of Comparative Advertisements," Journal of Advertising, 17 (September), 15-21. Jackson, Donald W., Jr., Stephen W. Brown, and Robert R. Harmon (1979), "Comparative Magazine Advertisements," Journal of Advertising Research, 19 (December), 21-26. Kavanoor, Sukumar, Dhruv Grewal, and Jeff Blodgett (1997), "Ads Promoting OTC Medications: A Multi-Study Examination of the Effect if Ad Credibility and Ad Format on Beliefs, Attitudes and Purchase Intentions," Journal of Business Research, forthcoming. Krugman, Herbert E. (1965), "The Impact of Television Advertising: Learning Without Involvement," Public Opinion Quarterly, 29 (Fall), 349-56. Lavidge, Robert J. and Gary A. Steiner (1961), "A Model for Predictive Measurements of Advertising Effectiveness," Journal of Marketing, 25 (October), 59-62. Levine, Philip (1976), "Commercials That Name Competing Brands," Journal of Advertising Research, 16 (December), 7-14. MacKenzie, Scott B., Richard J. Lutz, and George E. Belch (1986), "The Role of Attitude Toward the Ad as a Mediator of Advertising Effectiveness: A Test of Competing Explanations," Journal of Marketing Research, 23 (May), 130^3. Mazis, Michael B. (1976), "A Theoretical and Empirical Examination of Comparative Advertising," working paper. College of Business Administration, University of Florida, Gainesville. McDougall, G. H. G. (1976), "Comparative Advertising: An Empirical Investigation of the Role of Consumer Information," Working Paper No. 167, Department of Marketing, University of Western Ontario. Miniard, Paul W., Randall L. Rose, Michael J. Barone, and Kenneth C. Manning (1993), "On the Need for Relative Measures When Assessing Comparative Advertising Effects," Journal of Advertising, 22 (September), 41-57. Muehling, Darrel D. (1987), "Comparative Advertising: The Influence of Attitude-Toward-the-Ad on Brand Evaluation," Journal of Advertising, 16 (December), 4 3 ^ 9 . , Jeffrey J. Stoltman, and Sanford Grossbart (1990), "The Impact of Comparative Advertising on Levels of Message Involvement," Journal of Advertising, 19 (December), 41-50. Neiman, Janet (1987), "The Trouble With Comparative Ads," Ad Week, (January 12), BR4-5. Paivio, A. (1969), "Mental Imagery and Associative Leaming and Memory," Psychological Review, 76 (May), 241-63. , C. Yuiile, and S. A. Madigan (1968), "Concreteness, Imagery, and Meaningfulness Values of 925 Nouns," Journal of Experimental Psychology, 76 (January), 1-25. Park, C. Whan, V. Parker Lessig, and D. H. Lee (1990), "The Level and Nature of Product Knowledge and Ad Format Strategies," in Current Issues and Research in Advertising, James Leigh and Claude R. Martin, Jr., eds. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan, 125-54. Pechmann, Cornelia and Gabriel Esteban (1994), "Persuasion Processes Associated With Direct Comparative and Noncomparative Advertising and Implications for Advertising Effectiveness," Journal of Consumer Psychology, 2 (4), 403-32.
14 / Journal of Marketing, October 1997
and S. Ratneshwar (1991), "The Use of Comparative Advertising for Brand Positioning: Association Versus Differentiation," Journal of Consumer Research, 18 (September), 145-60. • and David W. Stewart (1990a), "The Effects of Comparative Advertisement on Attention, Memory and Purchase Intentions," Journal of Consumer Research, 17 (September), 180-91. and (1990b), "The Development of a Contingency Model of Comparative Advertising," Working Paper No. 90-108, Marketing Science Institute, Boston. and (1991), "How Direct Comparative Ads and Market Share Affect Brand Choice," Journal of Advertising Research, 31 (December), 47-55. Pride, William M., Charles W. Lamb, and Barbara A. Pletcher (1979), "The Informativeness of Comparative Advertisements: An Empirical Investigation," Journal of Advertising, 8 (June), 29-35. Rogers, John C. and Terrell G. Williams (1989), "Comparative Advertising Effectiveness: Practitioners ' Perceptions Versus Academic Research Findings," Journal of Advertising Research, 29 (October/November), 22-37. Rose, Randall L., Paul W. Miniard, Michael J. Barone, Kenneth C. Manning, and Brian D. Till (1993), "When Persuasion Goes Undetected: The Case of Comparative Advertising," Journal of Marketing Research, 30 (August), 315-30. Rosenthal, Robert (1984), Meta-Analytic Procedures for Social Research. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications. and Donald B. Rubin (1982), "A Simple, General Purpose Display of Magnitude of Experimental Effect," Journal of Educational Psychology, 74 (April), 166-69. Shimp, Terence A. and David C. Dyer (1978), "The Effects of Comparative Advertising Mediated by Market Position Spon-
soring Brand," Journal of Advertising, 3 (Summer), 13-19. Snyder, Rita (1992), "Comparative Advertising and Brand Evaluation: Toward Developing a Categorization Approach," Journal
of Consumer Psychology, 1 (I), 15-30.
Stewart, David W. and David H. Furse (1986), Effective TV Advertising: A Study of 1000 Commercials. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books. Sujan, Mita and Christine Dekleva (1987), "Product Categorization and Inference Making: Some Implications for Comparative Advertising," Journal of Consumer Research, 14 (September), 372-78. Swinyard, William R. (1981), "The Interaction Between Comparative Advertising and Copy Claim Variation," Journal of Marketing Research, 18 (May), 175-86. Tannenbaum, S. (1974), "Policy Statement and Guidelines for Comparative Advertising," American Advertising Agencies, April. Turgeon, Normand and David J. Barnaby (1988), "Comparative Advertising: Two Decades of Practice and Research," in Current Issues and Research in Advertising, James Leigh and Claude R. Martin, Jr., eds. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan, 41-65. Wilkie, William L. and Paul Farris (1975), "Comparison Advertising: Problems and Potential," Journal of Marketing, 39 (October), 7-15. Wilson, R. Dale and Aydin Muderrisoglu (1979), "An Analysis of Cognitive to Comparative Advertising," in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 7, Jerry C. Olson, ed. San Francisco, CA: Association for Consumer Research, 566-71. Wright, Peter L. (1973), "The Cognitive Processes Mediating Acceptance of Advertising," Journal of Marketing Research, 10 (February), 53-62.
Comparative Versus Noncomparative /15
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Comparative Advertising Essay
  • advertising Essay
  • Advertising Essay
  • Advertising Essay
  • Essay on Advertising
  • Advertising Essay
  • Comparative Advertising Essay
  • advertising Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free